# Code Review — ECR-007

**From:** Reviewer  
**To:** Guardian / Human  
**ECR:** ECR-007  
**BD:** BD-2026-007  
**Date:** 2026-08-07  
**Decision:** PASS  

## Checklist

| Item | Result | Notes |
|------|--------|-------|
| State machine boundary | PASS | lifecycle UNKNOWN/FORMING/CONFIRMED/COMPLETED; cycles[0]=ACTIVE |
| confidence explainability | PASS | cycle/phase/event/structure/volume/overall — not black-box |
| backward compatibility | PASS | top-level phases/events still Confirmed mirror |
| Live ≠ execution | PASS | execution_signal_from_wyckoff source=confirmed; live-only None |
| Confirmed thresholds | PASS | no intentional cut for Live; structural support fix is robustness (eaten spring) |

## Findings

1. Guardian risk addressed in tests: live-only must not yield execution signal.  
2. Summary UI partitions Confirmed vs Live (observation).  

## Decision

**PASS**